English Muffin Bread – Faux Sourdough-Style

English Muffin Bread recipe, tastes like sourdough, buttermilk recipe

English Muffin Bread – Faux Sourdough

This English Muffin Bread recipe is a “faux sourdough” and it is easy, delicious, and quite possibly the best toasting bread ever. Loaded with nooks and crannies, and with a dusting of cornmeal on the outside, this bread has that characteristic English Muffin crunch when toasted, as well as the tangy flavor of sourdough. If you’re a fan of English Muffins toasted to a golden brown and topped with your favorite butter, jelly or jam, I guarantee you will love this bread.  

I’ve been making English Muffin Bread for several years now; I adapted a recipe online to use my ancient sourdough starter instead of yeast. From the first moment I made it I wanted to share it with you! It’s just so darned good!

The sticking points in not sharing the recipe being:

  1. Not everyone has access to an ancient sourdough starter.
  2. Not everyone would want to mess with feeding a sourdough starter (you can make your own sourdough starter and you can buy sourdough starter, too. King Arthur Flour sells one here).
  3. It complicates the recipe just a bit and I was worried about you all being afraid of bread-making if it was too hard to do.

So, what I’ve devised here is bread that has a similar flavor to the sourdough English Muffin Bread I normally bake, without the hassle of a starter. Sourdough has a distinctive tangy flavor that’s mildly sour – hence the name “sourdough.”

It took a bit of experimentation, but I have finally hit on the method for you to make this Faux Sourdough English Muffin Bread yourselves. And the very good news is, it is easy.

What makes sourdough sour is the lactic acid in the starter; to replicate that flavor, I have used buttermilk which also contains lactic acid.  So, instead of water, I’ve used buttermilk. Easy as pie…or bread. Errrhmmm. This recipe has been tested using cultured buttermilk, which is readily available in your local market. So, let’s get baking!

I started baking bread when I was in college. I will tell you now, I had many, many failures. What I later discovered is that many of the directions in bread cookbooks lacked some simple tips that would ensure success. Once I learned what they were I was a bread-baking fool. Some bread-baking tips vary with types of bread, but these two I’m giving here apply to this particular bread.

First, it is important to feed your yeast before you begin. That’s a simple matter, but your bread won’t fail if you do this easy step. Active dry yeast is combined with sugar and warm (120° – 130°F) water. You’ll know that your yeast is viable (fresh) when this mixture bubbles up.

Secondly, it’s important to properly “proof” your bread. That is “allowing the dough to rise” that you’ll see in most recipes for bread. In this bread, there is no kneading, and just one rise before you bake it. You want to allow the bread to rise in a warm location; for the home bread baker that can be accomplished in your oven with just the light turned on. The contained space of the oven with the light on will create a warm, humid environment for the fermentation of the bread. You’ll need to remove the pans from the oven prior to preheating it to bake the bread.

You don’t really have to have any specialized equipment for this recipe, although an electric mixer is helpful. It is quite possible to prepare this bread by hand, stirring with a wooden spoon.

This recipe makes two standard-sized loaves. You will not believe how quickly you gobble them up! Do try it!


p.s: This bread freezes very well. Wrap the loaf in plastic wrap and place into a freezer compatible storage bag. Thaw to slice and toast.

5.0 from 2 reviews
English Muffin Bread - Faux Sourdough-Style
Prep time
Cook time
Total time
This English Muffin Bread recipe is a "faux sourdough" (with buttermilk giving it that sourdough tang), and it is easy, delicious, and quite possibly the best toasting bread ever. Loaded with nooks and crannies, and with a dusting of cornmeal on the outside, this bread has that distinctive crunch when toasted.
Serves: 2 loaves
  • 2 packages (1/4 ounce each) active dry yeast (this equals 1 tablespoon + 1½ teaspoons)
  • 1 tablespoon sugar
  • ½ cup warm water ((120° to 130°)*
  • 5 cups all-purpose flour, divided
  • 2 teaspoons salt
  • ¼ teaspoon baking soda
  • 3 cups warm buttermilk (120° to 130°)
  • Cornmeal (for dusting the pans and the tops of the bread)
  1. In a small bowl combine yeast, sugar and water.
  2. Set aside until the mixture has a heavy foam covering the surface.
  3. In a large bowl, combine 2 cups flour, salt and baking soda.
  4. Stir to combine.
  5. Once the yeast is foaming, add it to the flour mixture along with the warmed buttermilk.
  6. Beat on low-speed until just combined, scraping the bowl to incorporate all of the flour mixture. Beat on high for 3 minutes.
  7. Stir in remaining flour until incorporated. (batter will be stiff and sticky and there may be lumps...this is fine).
  8. Do not knead.
  9. Grease two 8" x 4" loaf pans.
  10. Sprinkle pans with cornmeal, covering the sides to the top edge of the pan.
  11. Spoon batter into the pans and sprinkle cornmeal on top.
  12. Cover and let rise in a warm place until the dough comes to the top edge of the pans, about 45 minutes. If you have used your oven with the light on to proof your bread, remove the loaf pans prior to preheating the oven.
  13. Bake in a preheated 375°F oven for 35 minutes, or until golden brown.
  14. Remove from pans immediately and cool on a wire rack.
*It helps to have a thermometer, but you can test this with your hand...it will be lukewarm.


About P ~ The Saucy Southerner

I started cooking when I was ten years old. For me, the process of cooking, from inception of a dish, to the execution, to the washing of the pots is sheer delight. I am now retired from a business I still own, in partnership with my husband. I used to work six days a week and still cook every night. Now, I'm gardening, still cooking, always having fun and hoping to share my joy with you. Thank you for reading...and commenting! P~
This entry was posted in Baking, Breads, Brunch. Bookmark the permalink.

10 Responses to English Muffin Bread – Faux Sourdough-Style

  1. I’m totally intrigued by this. Making! 🙂

  2. Derik says:

    That looks perfect. I just made some English muffin bread a few weeks ago and ended up making another batch the very next day. Love the texture you have on those slices.

  3. Joyce says:

    I made the English Muffin bread and we loved the taste and texture. I was reluctant to heat the liquids to 120-130, so used traditional 115 degrees. I used 8 inch pans as directed the first time, but the dough overflowed the pans and I had to remove some dough b/f baking.
    I made a second batch today (and used one 9 inch and one 8 inch pan) and both loaves collapsed in the middle while baking and were both undercooked in the middle when I removed after 35 minutes. Have you ever had this happen or know what might have caused this? Thanks! Joyce

  4. Clarinda Arsenault says:

    May I please have your recipe for True Sourdough English Muffin bread? Thank you!

    • Clarinda, Eliminate the yeast and the water. For the liquid, substitute 1 1/2 cups of proofed sourdough starter and two cups milk (or buttermilk, which I prefer). Add the sugar to the flour, salt and baking soda. The recipe will then follow according to the above.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Rate this recipe: